Skip to main content
insightfig

For insurance brokerages

More qualified quote requests. A stronger book of business.

Insurance is a crowded, price-compared market: shoppers check comparison sites, and a quote request for a contractor’s commercial package is usually worth more to your brokerage than one for a single auto policy. Brokerages grow by winning the lines they want and keeping clients at renewal. insightfig builds campaigns by line of business and market, plans around seasons and renewal timing, and measures cost per qualified quote request, with outcomes from your broker management system where available.

01 / The business model

Each line of business has its own economics

A home and auto bundle, a contractor’s commercial package, a fleet policy and a group benefits plan differ in premium, commission, underwriting effort and retention. The most valuable clients are often the ones who stay for years and add policies, so acquisition targets should reflect that, not first-year commission alone.
  • Personal lines are high-volume and price-sensitive, and comparison sites compete for the same searches.
  • Commercial lines take longer to quote, need more information and reward knowledge of the client’s industry.
  • Group benefits decisions involve owners, HR and finance, and often follow a renewal or a rate increase.
  • Demand follows renewal dates and the seasons, such as the start of contractor season.

02 / Common challenges

Where marketing budgets usually go wrong.

  1. 01

    Competing with comparison sites

    Aggregators and direct insurers bid heavily on broad terms like “cheap car insurance” and “home insurance quote”. Chasing those searches without a clear angle often means paying high click prices for the most price-driven shoppers.

  2. 02

    Price shoppers who never bind

    Some quote requests come from people collecting numbers to negotiate with their current insurer at renewal. Without qualification and lead-quality feedback, campaigns optimize toward them.

  3. 03

    Commercial and personal lines run the same way

    Commercial buyers search differently, need longer forms and take longer to decide than someone renewing home insurance. A shared campaign and landing page serves neither well, and hides which line produces value.

  4. 04

    Budgets that ignore seasons and renewals

    Flat monthly budgets miss the moments that matter: the start of contractor season, common renewal periods and the weeks after renewal notices arrive with higher premiums.

  5. 05

    Quotes that can’t be traced to policies

    A quote request isn’t a bound policy. Without connecting inquiries to outcomes in your broker management system, it’s hard to know which campaigns produce new business worth keeping.

03 / How we help

A program built for how your clients choose.

Campaigns by line of business

Separate campaigns, budgets and landing pages for commercial lines (contractors, fleet, professional liability, cyber), personal lines and group benefits.

Positioning a broker can win on

Messaging built around access to multiple insurers, advice, claims support or industry expertise, instead of competing with aggregators on price alone.

Fast, focused quote handling

Line-specific quote forms that ask only what your team needs, with automated acknowledgment and routing to the right broker, overseen by your team, because shoppers often contact several brokerages.

A season- and renewal-aware plan

Budgets planned around contractor season, renewal timing and your team’s quoting capacity, with retargeting to bring shoppers back when they’re ready.

Outcomes from your broker management system

Quote and bind outcomes from Applied Epic or your broker management system, where available, connected to campaigns so they optimize toward policies, not forms.

Want to see how this would apply to your brokerage?

Book a Strategy Call

04 / Advertising & measurement

Capabilities we bring to your campaigns.

All services
Google Search by line and city
Campaigns for specific needs (“contractor liability insurance Ontario”, “commercial auto insurance Mississauga”, “cyber insurance for small business”) with negatives for claims, login and job searches.
Microsoft Advertising
Search campaigns on Bing and the Microsoft network, managed with their own budgets and reporting rather than copied from Google.
Meta for personal lines & retargeting
Campaigns for home, auto and bundled policies in your markets, plus retargeting to bring quote-page visitors back, within Meta’s policies for insurance advertising.
LinkedIn for commercial & group benefits
Paid social by industry, company size and role to reach owners, HR leads and finance decision-makers with commercial and benefits offers.
Quote-form & call tracking
GA4 and Google Tag Manager tracking for quote requests and calls by line of business, with notice to callers wherever calls are recorded.
Line-of-business dashboards
Looker Studio reporting on spend, quote requests, qualified quotes and, where available, bound policies, by line and market.

Exhibit 01

What we measure, from first search to outcome

  1. 01Search for contractor insurance
  2. 02Quote request or call
  3. 03Qualified quote request
  4. 04Quote presented
  5. 05Policy bound
Platform-reportedBusiness outcomes: what we optimize toward
Each stage is tracked where your systems and privacy obligations allow. Reporting focuses on the later stages, the ones that reflect business value.

05 / Rules and obligations

Accurate claims and fair treatment of customers

In Ontario, broker advertising is regulated by RIBO (the Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario), and other provinces have their own insurance councils and regulators. Savings and price claims must be substantiated, the federal Competition Act prohibits misleading representations, and regulators expect brokerages to treat customers fairly. Privacy law also applies to the information you collect in quote forms. We build campaigns and forms with these obligations in mind, and your brokerage approves all messaging before launch.

How we work within the rules

  • Savings and price claims only where they can be substantiated.
  • Coverage described accurately, without implying that prices or approvals are guaranteed.
  • Quote forms that collect only what’s needed to follow up.
  • Brokerage review and approval of all messaging before launch.

insightfig is a marketing agency. We don’t provide legal or regulatory advice, and your organization remains responsible for meeting its professional obligations.

06 / Engagement process

What working together looks like.

Every engagement follows the same disciplined path. What we focus on at each step depends on your industry.
Our approach
  1. Step 01

    Strategy call

    A 30-minute conversation about your business, goals, markets and current marketing. No obligation.

    For insurance brokerages

    We’ll discuss your lines of business, target industries and markets, quoting capacity and which clients you want more of.

  2. Step 02

    Marketing assessment

    We review your ad accounts, tracking, landing pages and competitive landscape, and identify wasted spend and missed opportunities.

    For insurance brokerages

    We review campaigns, quote-form and call tracking, landing pages and, where available, how past quote requests turned into bound policies.

  3. Step 03

    Tailored proposal

    A recommended strategy, scope, channels and measurement plan, priced for your goals and complexity.

    For insurance brokerages

    A plan by line of business with a season- and renewal-aware budget, a qualified quote definition for each line and the measurement to track it.

  4. Step 04

    Launch, measure, improve

    We fix measurement first, launch in phases, and report monthly on qualified leads and cost per qualified lead, with regular strategic reviews.

    For insurance brokerages

    Priority lines launch first. We review quote quality with your brokers and expand once the economics of each line are clear.

07 / Questions

Frequently asked questions.

Something else on your mind? Ask us on a strategy call.

Can we compete with comparison sites on price searches?

Sometimes, but rarely head-on. Aggregators and direct insurers spend heavily on broad price searches. We usually focus budget where a broker has an advantage (specific industries, complex risks, bundled policies, local markets) and run measured tests before investing in broad personal lines terms.

Should commercial and personal lines be marketed separately?

Yes. They differ in who buys, how they search, what a quote requires and what a client is worth. Separate campaigns, landing pages and forms let each line be measured and budgeted on its own economics.

Can you connect campaigns to our broker management system?

Often, yes. Where Applied Epic or your broker management system allows exports or integration, we use minimal data (such as quote and bind status by line) to measure which campaigns produce new business. Where it doesn’t, we set up a simple shared feedback process with your team.

How do you handle RIBO and other advertising rules?

We write ads and landing-page recommendations with your regulator’s requirements in mind: substantiated savings claims, accurate descriptions of coverage and no misleading representations. Your brokerage approves everything before launch, and we aren’t a substitute for your own compliance review.

How is an engagement priced?

Each engagement is scoped to your goals, lines of business, markets and the channels involved. After a strategy call and assessment we recommend an approach, and the proposal sets out exactly what’s included and what it costs.

Book a strategy call

Let’s grow the lines of business you want more of.

Book a strategy call to talk through your lines, markets and renewal patterns, and where qualified quote requests should come from.

Book a Strategy Call

30-minute call · No obligation · Tailored proposal